The onerous lockdowns and state-run quarantine centers have created bitter resentment among citizens in affected areas. In cities like Urumqi in Inner Mongolia, citizens were locked down for as long as 100 days. And in many cities with major outbreaks, citizens were subjected to PCR tests that needed to be renewed every 48 hours. Proof of a current negative test, usually tracked via a smart-phone app, have been required to enter public venues, including grocery stores. By any measure, China’s policies have been emotionally draining for its citizens.
Western media has reported extensively on protests that have erupted in response to the draconian lockdowns.
But public protest is much more common in China than is generally reported in western media – the central government routinely reports on the number of protests, which have grown from 8,700 in 1993 to more than 180,000 in 2010. And as long as protests don’t directly challenge the CCP’s authority, they are quietly tolerated as a means for Chinese citizens to air their grievances, presumably against local government handling of corruption, the environment, labor issues, and other concerns.
But the scope, scale, and nature of the so-called “White Paper Protests”, also known as the “A4 Revolution”, represented a more direct challenge to the CCP’s and Xi Jinping’s policies. The terms “white paper” and “A4” are symbolic of censorship (a white paper has nothing on it).
Although unrelated to Beijing’s COVID policies, the Sitong Bridge Protest just prior to the 20th National Congress on October 13, 2022 was directed more against Chairman Xi and his perceived cult of personality, as well as human rights violations and censorship.
COVID-related protests began in early November, with incidents in Lanzhou triggered by the death of a 3-year old boy who did not receive tiely medical treatment due to COVID restrictions.
General protests against renewed lockdowns in Guangzhou began on November 5 , with migrant workers in Haizhu District breaking down metal barriers and demanding an end to lockdowns that prevented them from finding work. Other residents joined in protest against long lines for COVID testing and inability to find fresh and affordable produce.
The first major COVID-related protest occurred on November 22, 2022 at the Foxconn factory in Zhengzhou, home to the largest Apple factory in the world. While western media over-simplified workers’ grievances. On the one hand, workers were not allowed to leave the premises – this had as much to do with COVID policy as it did with operational continuity. And finally, workers who tested positive for COVID were not segregated from the other workers. Workers clashed with security forces in what was probably the most violent protests to date.
The second major COVID-related protest to attract western media attention occurred on November 25 in Xinjiang, after a residential complex fire killed 10 people when lockdown-related restrictions may have prevented people from escaping the burning building and hampered rescue efforts.
The Xinjiang fire triggered broad-based emotional support throughout China. In Nanjing, students started holding blank sheets of paper that became known as the White Paper Protests. And on November 26, a large group of protesters congregated on Wulumuqi Road in Shanghai, likewise holding white sheets of papers to honor those killed in the Xinjiang fire. The Shanghai incident was notable for the slogan used by some protesters – “step down” (下台), which is one of the few times protesters have demanded that Xi Jinping resign his posts as President of China and leader of the CCP.
Other protests followed in major cities, such as Chengdu, Beijing, Wuhan, and Hong Kong. It had become apparent that Beijing’s COVID policies had become counter-productive, at least insofar as they undermining the moral authority of the Party.
But while western media portrayed these protests in a dramatic light, it’s wishful thinking on the part of western politicians and media pundits to view these protests as the beginning of the end of the CCP’s grip on power. The average citizen is not nearly as focused on ideological issues as their western counterparts. They have been, and we believe will continue to be, quite willing to forego many of the freedoms associated with western democracies in return for continuous economic progress, which the CCP has delivered.